
Braun Mincher
Braun Mincher is the author of “The Secrets of Money: A Guide for Everyone on Practical Financial Literacy”. This blog entry is from Chapter 8 of his book and the fourth in a series of ten entries on this subject. For more on Braun click here.
When someone starts to drone on about what you shouldn’t do, it can be difficult to stay awake sometimes. Human beings were meant to be proactive. Don’t just tell me what not to do; tell me what to do.
Here’s one of the first things to do: Get yourself a 401(k).
Here’s what it is: First established in 1981 with final regulations in 1991, a 401(k) is an employer sponsored retirement plan named after a section of the US Internal Revenue Code (Section 401, Paragraph “k”—duh). Would you believe that Japan also has 401(k) programs modeled after the U.S. system and they, too, call it a “401(k)”—even though that number and letter correspond to absolutely nothing in that country? Some trivia with which to impress your friends.
A 401(k) is usually set up by a private corporation—not a government entity. For certain selected occupations, there are similar plans that work much the same way, but are given different names. For example, 403(b) Plans cover workers in educational institutions, churches, public hospitals, and non-profit organizations, and 457 Plans cover employees of state and local governments and certain tax-exempt entities. The self-employed are also eligible to setup their own 401(k) programs. Individuals or employees themselves are not eligible to sponsor their own 401(k) plan.
A 401(k) allows a worker to save for retirement while generally deferring income taxes on the saved money, growth and earnings until withdrawal, with the theory being that most people’s post-retirement income tax bracket will be less than it is today. This makes sense for the individual when one considers that it is logical to earn more money when working than when retired, right? So the idea here is that no income tax is withheld on the money contributed in the year that money is put into the 401(k). Furthermore, some people retire to states that do not have income taxes, since income is taxed on both a state as well as a federal level (with the exception of the no-income-tax states that were explained in a previous Chapter).
However, there is a new “Roth-401(k)” (named after a U.S. Senator by the name of … Roth). With this program, taxes are paid now, but not on the growth or withdrawal in the future. Wrap your mind around this twist: You put $1,000 in today. It produces earnings and grows in value. Eventually, due to appreciation, you get to withdraw, say, $10,000 from that original $1,000 investment. Forget tax brackets—the tax on $10,000 is larger than the tax on $1,000, right? That’s how the Roth program works. Using the aforementioned example, with a Roth IRA, when you draw out that $10,000, you pay no taxes, because you already paid taxes on the $1,000 you started with way back when you put that $1,000 in.
Because of this new wrinkle, Roth 401(k)s are becoming immensely popular. What you might be wondering is how does one designate which of the two programs one participates in. The way that works is this: Your employer (not you, unless you are self-employed) sets up the 401(k) or Roth 401(k) program. Setting up either such program requires the filing of certain forms with the IRS—an employer can’t simply say, “If you want, you can give me some of your money, I’ll add some of mine to it, and we’ll invest it together and call it a 401(k).” It doesn’t work that way.
It is possible that your employer will give you a choice between a traditional 401(k) and a Roth. You can see the advantages of both, though, and even if you favor one more than the other, they’re both good retirement vehicles.
If you are self-employed, or if you are the employer, then you must mull over the differences and decide which way to go. A good professional financial advisor and/or accountant can then help you set it up and make sure all the proper forms have been filled out and filed.
Usually, the employee can select from a number of investment options, such as a variety of mutual funds that emphasize stocks, bonds, and money market investments. Some plans also offer the option to purchase company stock. The key here is, the employee—you—gets some choice as to how the money is invested, and if you leave, you can take it with you. This, again, is in contrast to a company pension plan where you have no control over how the money is invested.
This is also where that word “diversify” comes up again. Again, it is best not to have more than 20% of your money in any one stock, fund, or investment apparatus. Think about the people who tied up all their benefits in Enron or WorldCom stock.
Assets held by the plans are generally protected from creditors of the account holder (i.e., if you get sued or go bankrupt). In other words, if you declare bankruptcy, your 401(k) cannot be touched. In the case of EMPLOYER bankruptcy, assets in a 401(k) are protected, while pension plans usually are NOT (another advantage of 401(k)s over traditional employer pension plans).
Here is the biggest benefit to a 401(k): Many companies “match” an employee’s contributions, up to 1, 2, 3% or more of their salaries. This is like “free money” for the employees, and you are crazy if you do not max out these contributions! The “match” is also tax deductible to the company. Like health plans, this is an important employee perk, and many employers are offering it in order to get quality employees.
Despite this, unlike health care benefits, some employees don’t bother getting involved in their employer’s 401(k) program. This is insanity. I am urging you to be a saver anyway; why not invest in a program where some of your savings may, in fact, be matched by someone else? Picture putting $50 a week into a savings account, and then handing your employer some deposit slips so that he or she could also put $50 per week, every week, into YOUR savings account. Mind-blowing, isn’t it?
Other employees still leave money on the table by only “dipping their toe in the water” with 401(k) investment. At a minimum, I strongly urge you to put in as much money as your employer will match. Using the previous example, what if I told you that if you put in up to $100 per week, I would also put $100 per week into your account. If you only put in $50, then that is all I would put in as well. Why, then, would you stop at $50? Put in whatever I am willing to put in. Take my money, please. It’s like the reverse of the street person standing on the corner asking for spare change. A 401(k) is like a rich guy standing on the corner handing out spare change. Take it!
Furthermore, money placed into your interest-bearing checking or your regular savings account is not tax-deductible or tax-deferred. A 401(k) is. Earn $50,000 a year and put $5,000 a year into a savings account, you still pay income tax on $50,000. Earn $50,000 and put $5,000 into a traditional 401(k), you pay income tax on only $45,000. Which is better?
You can contribute up to $15,500 to a 401(k) in 2007. This will be indexed for inflation in future years, increasing in $500 increments. For 2007, the maximum total contribution (what both you and your employer can contribute) is the lesser of your total annual earnings or $45,000. Employees are generally able to contribute up to 15% of their earnings to a 401(k).
With a traditional 401(k), you must start to draw out assets after reaching the age of 70½, but can do so as early as 59½ in most cases. Only a Roth IRA is not subject to minimum distribution rules. There is a specific calculation that the government has devised that dictates how much money must be withdrawn from your 401(k) upon reaching this age of (assumed) retirement. The penalty for not doing this—50% of the amount that should have been withdrawn —is one of the most severe that the IRS levies. So, remember that this program does have certain rules and regulations that must be followed. Following them is not onerous, so don’t be scared off. But bear in mind that they are there.
If you really need to get at your 401(k) money early, there is a 10% penalty for early withdrawal, in addition to ordinary income taxes on that money, which is considered regular income upon withdrawal. There do exist, though, some exceptions for borrowing for home purchases, secondary education expenses, medical care and the like. Check with your accountant or your employer’s human resources (HR) person before contemplating early withdrawal.
If you change jobs, you can take your 401k with you. This is important, as some people are under the misconception that they must either stay at a job they dislike so that they do not lose that money, or that they MUST cash out that money and pay a 10% penalty if they leave that employment. Not to worry, the government has already addressed that issue and you are covered. If your new employer has a 401(k) Plan, you can convert yours into theirs in what is called a “Direct Rollover.” Even if your new employer does not offer a 401(k) program, you can still do this via something called an individual IRA Rollover (more on this later). You even have the third (and least desirable option) of keeping your 401(k) with your old employer. For obvious reasons, this is not a great idea since you would most likely lose daily controls over that money’s management.
Too many people ignore all of these options and simply cash out and pay the 10% penalty. Dumb, dumb, dumb, dumb. Worse yet, some then take that money and say, “Wow, what a windfall! I think I’ll go out and buy a boat.” You’ve now just thrown away a whole lot of savings, defeating the whole concept.
This is a major hurdle in savings and investment mentality in general. When we are children, parents often tell us, “If you want that expensive toy, you’re going to have to save for it and buy it yourself.” On the surface, this is good parenting in its attempt to mold young people’s minds about hard work, saving, and reward. The problem is, the reward is too easily obtained and has negligible value. So the kid saves for that hot new toy. He buys it. Six weeks later, he’s bored with the toy and it’s thrown into the back of the closet. The kid hasn’t learned to save for anything of important lasting value, such as LIVING. And this is hard because the younger we are, the less we think about tomorrow. Oh, we might think about tomorrow, as in actual tomorrow. On Monday, we think about Tuesday. What we don’t grow up thinking enough about is Tuesday, sixty years from now; when we’re old and can no longer work.
Another catch to the whole “leaving my old job and taking with me the 401(k) I had there” is simple housekeeping. Make sure the check for your cash-out (it is still a type of cash-out, unless you decide to leave it at your old employer) is written out to the new plan and not to you personally. If it is made out to you, you will have to pay the 10% penalty and the income tax. Or, better yet, go the “Direct Rollover” route and never even touch the check.
401(k)s are great and you should avail yourself of them. The tax advantages, whether you are using a traditional or a Roth type, are substantial. Again, this is an example of the government creating incentives and disincentives to direct the populace to do certain things and not do certain other things. As Social Security continues to have its problems, the federal government is hoping to have as many people saving on their own—and they consider a 401(k) something that you do on your own, even though it usually involves an employer. In this way, if Social Security benefits need to be cut more in the future, less people are likely to be adversely affected. In fact, as you may know, Social Security benefits are now taxed if one’s total income from all sources exceeds a certain level. It’s a give away/take away. Social Security is fine for people who are truly indigent—it keeps them alive. I hope it stays in existence for their benefit. But for the rest of us, all signs are pointed toward us forgetting about it and taking care of ourselves —with the occasional governmental incentive.
ETF Pick of the Week – Australian Dollar (FXA) 1/24/2009
Carl Delfeld
Carl Delfeld is head of the global advisory firm Chartwell Partners and editor of Chartwell Advisor . He served as a director on the executive board of the Asian Development Bank during the administration of President George H. W. Bush, and he is the author of The New Global Investor . Click here for more analysis from Delfeld, or to subscribe to Chartwell Advisor. click here.
Overview and Rationale:
A contrarian play, FXA should benefit from any rebound in commodity and energy prices, intervention to weaken the Japanese yen, perception that the currency is oversold and the attraction of a 7% yield.
In 2007 Australia had about 13% of world reserves of iron ore and was ranked fourth after Ukraine (19%), Russia (16%) and China (14%). In terms of contained iron, Australia has about 15% of the world’s EDR and is ranked second behind Russia (19%). Australia produces around 16% of the world’s iron ore and is ranked third behind China (32%) and Brazil (19%).
While South Africa still has the world’s largest reserve of gold at 6000 tons (14.3%), Australia has the second largest reserve with approximately 12% of the world’s holdings.
Japanese investors seeking higher yields in foreign bond markets, such as in Australia and New Zealand, have been brutalized in recent months, with the Aussie dollar and NZ kiwi losing roughly 45% of their value against the yen to their lowest levels this decade.
FXA also offers a nice yield of 7.3% and also provides a nice hedge on the U.S. Dollar. Though recently weak, the Aussie dollar, it may reverse course as global markets concern over the Fed printing press and inflationary pressures returns.
Catalyst:
From a technical perspective, the timing to begin building a position in FXA looks attractive. The AUDUSD chart shows that the AUD has fallen from near parity with the USD at .95 to .67. During the past decade the AUD has traded above .65 for nearly 7 out of the last 10 years. The fall of the AUD has been brutal and is an outlier compared with the performance of other major currencies.
Risk Factor: Moderate given the depressed state of energy & commodity prices.
Risk Management: Suggest an 8% trailing stop loss.
Tip: You may wish to scale into a position at a price of $65 or lower.